Tarte Double Take Eyeliner Review 2026: Complete Guide

Tarte Double Take Eyeliner Review 2026: Complete Guide

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you click our links and make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.

If you want one eyeliner that can draw a clean wing and also define the waterline, Tarte Double Take Eyeliner may already be on your list. This product has stayed popular because it gives you two tools in one pen. You get a liquid liner on one side and a gel pencil on the other side. That sounds great on paper, but real value depends on how it feels on the eye, how long it lasts, and whether both sides work well enough to justify the price.

In this 2026 review, I will break down what this eyeliner does well, where it falls short, and who should buy it. I also looked at current product details from Tarte, Sephora, Ulta, and Amazon so this post uses fresh information instead of old guesses. If you want a simple answer before you spend your money, keep reading. This review is written in a clear and friendly way, and it will help you decide fast.

Tarte Double Take Eyeliner Review 2026: Complete Guide

Key Takeaways

  1. Tarte Double Take Eyeliner stands out because it gives you a liquid liner and a gel pencil in one product. That means you can make a sharp wing with one end and define the lash line or waterline with the other. This setup is very useful for people who like quick makeup and want fewer products in their bag.
  2. The liquid side is the real star for many users. It dries fast, looks dark, and helps create a neat line with less effort. Reviews on Tarte, Sephora, and Ulta often praise the strong color and good wear. The pencil side gets mixed feedback, but the liquid side keeps this eyeliner popular.
  3. The pencil side works best for people who like soft definition instead of a dramatic smoky eye. It can tightline the upper lash line well, and it helps fill small gaps between lashes. Some users say it feels smooth, while others say it can feel a bit dry after some use. That split in feedback matters.
  4. The formula checks many practical boxes. Tarte and Ulta list it as vegan, waterproof, ophthalmologist tested, dermatologist tested, and safe for contact lens wearers. The gel pencil includes Amazonian clay, and the liquid side dries to a semi matte finish. Those details make it easier to trust for long days.
  5. At about $26 in 2026, this is a mid range eyeliner with a premium feel. It is worth it if you will use both ends often. If you mostly want a liquid liner or mostly want a pencil, a separate lower cost option may give you better value. That is why alternatives matter, and I will cover the best three later in this post.

Tarte Double Take Eyeliner

tarte double take eyeliner – 2-in-1 Liquid & Gel Eyeliner for Bold All-Day Wear, Waterproof, Easy...
  • creates a wide range of eye looks with longwear 2-in-1 liquid & gel pencil eyeliner
  • Amazonian clay-infused gel pencil glides along the inner rim to define & tightline
  • slick liquid eyeliner goes on glossy & dries instantly to a semi-matte, opaque finish

Last update on 2026-10-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Tarte Double Take Eyeliner is a dual ended product with a liquid liner on one side and a gel pencil on the other. That is the whole reason people keep buying it. You do not need to open two separate products to finish one eye look. The liquid side is made for a defined line or wing. The pencil side is made for tightlining, contouring the eyes, and adding depth near the lashes. It is a simple idea, but it solves a real problem.

Right now, the product is listed around $26 at Sephora, and Amazon shows a strong 4.5 star average from about 800 reviews for the main listing. Tarte also shows strong customer feedback on its own site for the travel size version, with shoppers praising the liquid side, travel friendly size, and smooth use. That gives this eyeliner a good mix of brand support and user support. That is a strong start for any review.

The formula claims also look good in 2026. Ulta lists it as vegan, waterproof, 12 hour wear, ophthalmologist tested, dermatologist tested, and safe for contact lens wearers. Those are practical features, not empty buzzwords. For many buyers, that makes this eyeliner feel safer and easier to trust for daily wear.

First Look and Packaging

The packaging is sleek and easy to understand. One end holds the liquid liner. The other end holds the twist up gel pencil. That sounds basic, but it matters because some dual products feel bulky or confusing. This one feels neat in the hand, and the layout makes sense right away. You do not need a learning period just to hold it correctly.

The liquid side uses a soft precision tip that helps you draw both thin and thicker lines. This is helpful if your eye look changes from day to day. You can do a small line for work, then build a bolder wing for dinner or events. The pencil side twists up from the base, which is also easy for quick touch ups. The fact that both sides live in one tube makes this product great for a travel bag, gym pouch, or office makeup kit.

Tarte also sells a travel size version, and reviews on the brand site mention that the smaller size works well for on the go use. That tells me the design is part of the product appeal, not just the formula. A good eyeliner should feel easy before it even touches the eye. If you want one product that cuts down clutter and keeps your routine simple, the packaging is a real plus here.

Formula and Key Features

The feature list is one of the strongest parts of this eyeliner. According to Ulta, the gel pencil is infused with Amazonian clay, and the formula also uses mineral pigments. The liquid side goes on glossy and then dries down to a semi matte, opaque finish. That means you get a fresh dark line at first, but it settles into a cleaner final look. That finish works well for daily makeup because it looks polished without looking too shiny.

This eyeliner is also sold as waterproof and long wear. Tarte calls out 12 hour wear, and the brand site says the product is made to create serious double takes with its liquid and gel formulas. Those brand claims match a lot of the review feedback. Many users like how the liquid side stays put and keeps the line dark through long days. That matters if you deal with oily lids, heat, long work hours, or full day events.

Ulta also lists several trust signals that many buyers look for now. The product is vegan, ophthalmologist tested, dermatologist tested, and safe for contact lens wearers. Those details are very useful, especially if your eyes get irritated easily or if you wear liner close to the waterline. On paper, the formula is strong. The only real question is how both ends perform in daily use, and that is where the review gets more honest.

How It Applies on the Eyes

Application is where this eyeliner earns most of its praise. The liquid side is the easier winner. It lays down dark pigment fast, and the tip helps make a clean line without too much pressure. If you like a small wing, this side feels friendly. If you like a thicker cat eye, it can do that too. It gives control without feeling stiff, and that makes a big difference for people who rush through makeup in the morning.

The pencil side has a different job. It is best for tightlining, filling gaps between lashes, or adding a soft line near the bottom lashes. It is less about drama and more about definition. Some users say this side glides nicely and does not tug. Tarte review highlights even mention that the gel side feels smooth on the eyes. At the same time, some Ulta and user comments suggest that the pencil side can feel dry for certain people. So the experience may depend on your eye area and how fresh the product is.

A past review from Makeup and Beauty Blog praised the liquid side heavily and compared it favorably to another well known liquid liner. That review also liked the convenience of having a pencil on the other end. That matches what many current buyers still seem to feel. The liquid end makes the biggest impact, while the pencil end is useful but less exciting.

Top 3 Alternative for Tarte Double Take Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR Wear, Black
  • Waterproof Matte Liquid Eyeliner: Get the perfect long lasting cat eye look with NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink...
  • Precise Tip: Our ultra precise tip is flexible and Easy to Use; Every stroke is unbelievably fluid for a defined...
  • All Eyes On Eye Makeup: Complete your look with our full range of eye makeup products ranging from eyeshadow...

Last update on 2026-10-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip | Lasting Satin Finish...
  • MULTI-AWARD WINNER: A classic, our Stay All Day waterproof liquid eye liner brings a whole new level of artistry...
  • LONG-LASTING: Our waterproof liquid liner glides on with ease, dries quickly, and won't smudge or run...
  • THE PERFECT LINE: The fine marker-like tip offers precise application for everyone. Our amazing satin finish...

Last update on 2026-10-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 0.01 oz | Waterproof pencil eyeliner with...
  • LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and...
  • UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
  • EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic...

Last update on 2026-10-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

If Tarte Double Take Eyeliner feels a little pricey, or if you mainly want one type of liner instead of a dual product, these three options make sense. The first is NYX Epic Ink Liner. This one is a smart pick if your favorite part of Tarte is the liquid side. It has a very large review count on Amazon, strong ratings, and a lower price. It is one of the easiest value picks if you want a sharp black line and strong wear.

The second is Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. This is for people who want a more premium liquid liner and care a lot about tip control. It is a classic choice for wings, and Amazon shows a strong review base here too. If you never use pencil liner and only want a high performing liquid formula, this can be a better fit than Tarte.

The third is Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner. This is the choice for people who mostly want the pencil experience. It is lower in price, widely loved, and easy to find. Amazon also shows it as a strong seller with a very large review count. Together, these three products cover the main reasons people buy Tarte in the first place. You can choose based on whether you care most about liquid precision, premium liquid wear, or affordable pencil definition.

Wear Test and Smudge Test

A dual eyeliner only feels worth it if it lasts. Based on current retailer details and user feedback, the wear story here is mostly positive. Tarte and Ulta both frame the product as waterproof and long wear, and Tarte points to 12 hour wear. Many shoppers on Tarte and Sephora also mention that the liquid side keeps its shape well and stays visible through the day. That is the part of the formula that inspires the most trust.

The liquid liner seems best for long wear. It dries fast and is less likely to move once it sets. This makes it a good match for long workdays, dinner plans, or warm weather. Tarte reviews mention that it helps users get a straight line and that it stays on well. Older editorial feedback from Makeup and Beauty Blog also said the liner still looked great after a full day of work, errands, and exercise. That does not mean every eye type will get the same result, but it supports the strong wear claims.

The pencil side is more mixed in a smudge test. Some people love it for the upper and lower lash line. Others say it can smudge or feel softer than expected. That does not make it bad. It simply means the pencil side is best seen as a support tool, while the liquid side is the main reason to buy. If you want the whole product for all day wing wear, it performs well. If you want an all star waterline pencil, results may vary more.

Who Will Love This Eyeliner

This eyeliner is a very good match for people who like fast routines. If you want to finish your liner with one product instead of reaching for two or three, this one makes life easier. The liquid side gives shape. The pencil side adds depth near the lashes. That simple pairing saves time, especially on busy mornings.

It is also a smart choice for people who enjoy defined eyes without carrying a full makeup bag. The dual design works well for travel, office touch ups, dance events, weekends away, and daily use. Tarte customer reviews for the travel size version mention that it is great for competitions and on the go use. That says a lot about real life convenience. If your makeup style often includes a wing plus a waterline or lash line touch, this product fits naturally into that routine.

Another good match is someone with sensitive eyes who still wants a long wear formula. Ulta lists this eyeliner as ophthalmologist tested, dermatologist tested, and safe for contact lens wearers. Those details offer peace of mind. Of course, everyone reacts differently, but the product clearly tries to serve buyers who need more than just color. In short, this eyeliner is best for people who want convenience, dark pigment, and strong liquid liner performance in one tube. If that sounds like you, the product has a lot to offer.

Where It Falls Short

No eyeliner is perfect, and this one has one clear weak point. The pencil side gets less love than the liquid side. Some users say it glides well and helps define the eye. Others say it can feel dry or less smooth than expected. That matters because the whole value idea depends on both ends being good. If one side feels average, the dual design loses some shine.

Another small issue is price value. At around $26, this is not cheap. That is fine if you use both ends often. But if you mainly buy it for the liquid side, there are lower cost options that do a similar job. If you mainly buy it for the pencil side, there are also cheaper pencil liners with huge fan bases. This product makes the most sense for people who truly want the two in one format.

There is also a practical truth with dual products. You may finish one side before the other. If your liquid side runs out first, you still have the pencil attached. If your pencil dries up or becomes less useful first, you are still paying for it in the original price. That imbalance can annoy regular users. So while the concept is smart, it works best for makeup lovers whose habits fit both ends in equal measure.

Is It Worth the Price in 2026

For the right buyer, yes, this eyeliner is worth the price in 2026. The product still offers a useful format, good brand trust, and strong liquid liner performance. Sephora lists it at $26, which places it in the mid range beauty space. That is not a budget buy, but it is also not extreme for a makeup item that combines two functions. If you use both ends often, the value is easier to justify.

The liquid side does a lot of the heavy lifting. It gives dark color, quick drying wear, and decent control for a wing. The pencil side adds extra use if you like tightlining or adding softness near the lashes. In that case, you may save space and time with one tube instead of two separate liners. That is where the product earns its keep.

Still, value depends on your habits. If you are a liquid liner person and rarely touch pencil liner, you can spend less with NYX or spend in a more focused way with Stila. If you mainly want a pencil, Revlon may give you better value. This is why I would call Tarte a smart buy, but not a universal buy. It is worth it for people who like the full dual format and want a cleaner beauty bag. It is less worth it for shoppers with one very specific liner need.

Tips to Get the Best Results

A few small habits can make this eyeliner work better. Start with clean, dry lids. If your eyelids get oily fast, press a little powder or eye primer on the lid first. That helps the liquid side grip the skin and hold the wing shape longer. A smooth base makes a big difference, even with a waterproof formula.

Use the pencil side first if you want a fuller lash line. Tightline close to the roots of the lashes, then use the liquid side to draw the visible line above it. This makes the final look richer without needing a very thick wing. It also helps fill tiny gaps between lashes. For beginners, this order can feel easier because the pencil gives you a visual guide.

Tarte also shares a helpful wing tip through Ulta. Draw a thin line away from the outer corner, then connect it back to the center of the lash line. After that, fill in the space with one or two passes. This method keeps the wing neat and balanced. If the pencil side starts to feel less creamy over time, use shorter strokes instead of dragging it in one long line. That reduces tugging and keeps the application more comfortable. With simple prep and the right order, this eyeliner performs much better and feels easier to control.

Final Verdict

Tarte Double Take Eyeliner remains a strong and useful product in 2026. The main reason is clear. The liquid side performs well, looks dark, and helps create sharp lines with less stress. The pencil side is useful for tightlining and soft definition, even if it does not impress everyone in the same way. Overall, the product feels thoughtful and practical.

I would recommend it most to people who really want a dual product and will use both ends. It is also a nice fit for travel, daily makeup, and simple routines that still want polished eyes. The waterproof claim, vegan formula, and eye safety testing also add confidence for buyers who care about comfort and wear time.

My honest score is 8.5 out of 10. The score stays high because the liquid side is very good and the full concept is genuinely handy. The score does not go higher because the pencil side gets mixed reactions and the price makes shoppers compare it with lower cost single purpose liners. So is it a good buy? Yes, for the right person. If you want one tube that covers your wing and your lash line, this eyeliner still deserves attention. If you want only one format, one of the alternatives may serve you better.

FAQs

Is Tarte Double Take Eyeliner good for beginners?

Yes, especially the liquid side. The tip helps you draw thin or thicker lines with decent control, and the two in one format keeps your routine simple. Beginners who want one easy product often find this setup less confusing than carrying separate liners.

Is Tarte Double Take Eyeliner really waterproof?

The brand and retailers list it as waterproof, and many users say the liquid side wears well through long days. The pencil side can be a little more mixed depending on your eye area, but the liquid end has the stronger long wear reputation.

Does the pencil side smudge?

It can for some users. Some people love it for tightlining and soft definition. Others feel it is less reliable than the liquid side. This is the biggest caution point in most feedback.

What is the best alternative if I only want liquid liner?

NYX Epic Ink Liner is the best lower cost pick, while Stila Stay All Day is a strong premium pick. Both are better choices if you do not need a pencil end at all.

Is Tarte Double Take Eyeliner worth buying in 2026?

Yes, if you want a dual eyeliner and will use both sides often. If you only care about one side, you may get better value from a separate liner. That is the simplest answer.

Similar Posts